vs Other Leagues

MLS All-Star Game: Format, History & Results

Complete guide to the MLS All-Star Game, including format changes, how players are selected, memorable games, and full results history.

The MLS All-Star Game has been one of the league's marquee annual events since 1996, but it has also been one of its most frequently reinvented. The format has shifted from East vs. West matchups to MLS vs. international club opponents, and most recently to MLS vs. Liga MX, reflecting the league's evolving identity and its effort to create spectacles that resonate beyond the existing fan base.

Understanding the All-Star Game's history and format changes tells a broader story about MLS's growth and how the league positions itself against international competition. For a detailed comparison of MLS and its closest rival on the continental stage, see our MLS vs. Liga MX breakdown.

Current Format: How the MLS All-Star Game Works

As of the most recent editions, the MLS All-Star Game uses a format that pits a squad of MLS All-Stars against a selected opponent. Here is how the current system operates.

Player Selection

The MLS All-Star roster is assembled through a combination of three selection methods:

Fan voting: Fans vote online for players at each position. Fan voting determines the starting XI (or a portion of it), giving supporters a direct role in shaping the squad. Voting typically opens several weeks before the game and generates millions of votes.

Commissioner's picks: The MLS commissioner selects additional players to fill out the roster. These picks often address positional needs, recognize players who deserve All-Star recognition but may not have won the fan vote, and ensure representation from clubs across the league.

Head coach selections: The All-Star head coach (typically the coach of the host city's MLS team or the reigning MLS Cup champion's coach) selects the remaining roster spots. These picks tend to emphasize tactical fit and ensure the All-Star squad has the balance needed to be competitive.

The total roster size is typically 26 players, mirroring a standard MLS matchday squad.

The Opponent

The choice of opponent has varied over the years, and it has become one of the defining features of the modern All-Star Game. Recent opponents have included:

  • Liga MX All-Stars (2021-2024): A direct MLS vs. Liga MX matchup that plays into the intensifying rivalry between the two leagues
  • European clubs: Prior to the Liga MX format, MLS All-Stars faced elite European clubs visiting the United States during their preseason tours

The Liga MX format has been particularly popular because it taps into the genuine competitive tension between the two largest soccer leagues in North America. CONCACAF Champions Cup results, cross-border player movement, and cultural rivalry give the MLS vs. Liga MX All-Star matchup a edge that exhibition games against European clubs sometimes lacked.

Game Format

The match itself follows standard soccer rules: two 45-minute halves, with liberal substitutions allowed (both teams can make unlimited substitutions to ensure all selected players get playing time). If the match is tied after regulation, a penalty shootout determines the winner.

The All-Star Game is an exhibition -- no trophies, standings points, or competitive consequences are at stake. But the MLS vs. Liga MX format has injected genuine competitiveness, with players and coaches treating the match as a matter of league pride.

Complete History of MLS All-Star Game Results

East vs. West Era (1998-2001, 2004)

The original format pitted the Eastern Conference All-Stars against the Western Conference All-Stars, mirroring all-star game formats from the NFL and NBA.

| Year | Result | Location | |------|--------|----------| | 1998 | MLS USA 6-1 MLS World | Orlando, FL | | 1999 | West 6-4 East | San Diego, CA | | 2000 | East 9-4 West | Columbus, OH | | 2001 | East 6-6 West (East wins on PKs) | San Jose, CA | | 2004 | East 3-2 West | Washington, D.C. |

Note: The 1998 game used an MLS USA vs. MLS World (international players) format rather than East vs. West. The 2002 and 2003 games used a different format (MLS vs. U.S. national team, discussed below).

The East vs. West games were high-scoring but often lacked the competitive intensity that distinguishes a meaningful match from a glorified scrimmage. Double-digit combined goals reflected a lack of defensive effort, which was expected in an exhibition but limited the event's credibility.

MLS vs. International Opponents Era (2002-2019)

Starting in 2005, MLS shifted to an MLS All-Stars vs. visiting international club format. This became the game's most enduring setup, lasting (with some variations) through 2019.

| Year | Result | Opponent | Location | |------|--------|----------|----------| | 2002 | MLS All-Stars 3-2 U.S. National Team | USMNT | Washington, D.C. | | 2003 | MLS All-Stars 3-1 Guadalajara | Chivas | Carson, CA | | 2005 | MLS All-Stars 4-1 Fulham | Fulham FC | Columbus, OH | | 2006 | MLS All-Stars 1-0 Chelsea | Chelsea FC | Chicago, IL | | 2007 | MLS All-Stars 2-0 Celtic | Celtic FC | Denver, CO | | 2008 | MLS All-Stars 3-2 West Ham | West Ham United | Toronto, ON | | 2009 | MLS All-Stars 1-1 Everton (MLS wins on PKs) | Everton FC | Sandy, UT | | 2010 | MLS All-Stars 2-5 Manchester United | Manchester United | Houston, TX | | 2011 | MLS All-Stars 0-4 Manchester United | Manchester United | Harrison, NJ | | 2012 | MLS All-Stars 3-2 Chelsea | Chelsea FC | Chester, PA | | 2013 | MLS All-Stars 3-1 Roma | AS Roma | Kansas City, KS | | 2014 | MLS All-Stars 2-1 Bayern Munich | Bayern Munich | Portland, OR | | 2015 | MLS All-Stars 2-1 Tottenham | Tottenham Hotspur | Commerce City, CO | | 2016 | MLS All-Stars 1-2 Arsenal | Arsenal FC | San Jose, CA | | 2017 | MLS All-Stars 1-1 Real Madrid (Real wins on PKs) | Real Madrid | Chicago, IL | | 2018 | MLS All-Stars 1-1 Juventus (Juventus wins on PKs) | Juventus FC | Atlanta, GA | | 2019 | MLS All-Stars 0-3 Atletico Madrid | Atletico Madrid | Orlando, FL |

The international opponent format produced some of the All-Star Game's most memorable moments. The 2014 victory over Bayern Munich -- featuring Landon Donovan's farewell All-Star appearance -- and the 2006 win over Chelsea were highlights. The defeats against Manchester United in 2010 and 2011 were reality checks about the quality gap.

The format worked well as a spectacle: fans in host cities got to see world-famous clubs and players, and the matches drew attention from international media. But critics argued that the games were ultimately friendlies where European clubs were in preseason mode and MLS All-Stars had limited preparation time together.

MLS vs. Liga MX Era (2021-Present)

The shift to MLS vs. Liga MX capitalized on the growing rivalry between the two leagues.

| Year | Result | Location | |------|--------|----------| | 2021 | MLS All-Stars 1-1 Liga MX All-Stars (MLS wins on PKs) | Los Angeles, CA | | 2022 | MLS All-Stars 2-1 Liga MX All-Stars | Minneapolis, MN | | 2023 | MLS All-Stars 1-1 Liga MX All-Stars (MLS wins on PKs) | Washington, D.C. | | 2024 | MLS All-Stars 1-0 Liga MX All-Stars | Columbus, OH |

Note: The 2020 All-Star Game was canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

MLS has dominated this format, winning every edition through 2024. The results reflect MLS's growing financial and competitive strength relative to Liga MX, though the exhibition context limits how much can be read into any single result. The CONCACAF Champions Cup, where clubs meet in competitive matches, provides a more reliable measure of the league-vs-league comparison. For that analysis, see our MLS vs. Liga MX deep dive.

Memorable All-Star Game Moments

Landon Donovan's Farewell (2014)

The 2014 All-Star Game in Portland was Landon Donovan's last All-Star appearance before his retirement. Donovan, MLS's all-time leading scorer and assist provider at the time, entered as a substitute and helped the MLS All-Stars defeat Bayern Munich 2-1. The game served as a tribute to the greatest American-born player of his generation and one of the most important figures in MLS history.

Beating Chelsea in 2006

The 2006 All-Star Game in Chicago saw the MLS All-Stars defeat Jose Mourinho's Chelsea 1-0, with Dwayne De Rosario scoring the winner. Chelsea had won the Premier League in 2005 and 2006, making the result a genuine upset (even accounting for Chelsea's preseason fitness levels). The victory was a confidence boost for a league that still dealt with constant questions about its quality.

The 2010 Manchester United Rout

Manchester United's 5-2 demolition of the MLS All-Stars in Houston was a humbling reminder of the talent gap. Wayne Rooney scored twice, and the Red Devils' quality was evident throughout. The game highlighted both the entertainment value of bringing top European clubs to MLS venues and the on-field reality that MLS was still a tier below Europe's elite.

The Inaugural MLS vs. Liga MX Match (2021)

The first MLS vs. Liga MX All-Star Game in Los Angeles marked a format shift that felt culturally significant. Played at Banc of California Stadium (LAFC's home), the game featured a penalty shootout finish that MLS won. The atmosphere -- charged with the genuine rivalry between the two leagues and their fan bases -- validated the format change. The MLS vs. Liga MX rivalry has since become one of the most compelling narratives in North American soccer.

Skills Challenge and Events

In recent years, the All-Star festivities have expanded beyond the game itself to include:

  • Skills Challenge: Players compete in shooting accuracy, crossbar challenges, touch competitions, and other skill-based events. The Skills Challenge has become a fan favorite and generates significant social media engagement.
  • MLS All-Star Concert: A music event tied to the All-Star festivities, typically featuring popular artists.
  • Fan events: Interactive experiences, player appearances, and community events in the host city during the week leading up to the game.

These ancillary events reflect MLS's understanding that the All-Star Game is as much a marketing and fan engagement platform as it is a sporting event.

How All-Star Selection Reflects League Trends

The composition of All-Star rosters over the years mirrors MLS's evolution:

Early years (1996-2005): Rosters dominated by American and occasionally Latin American players. Few big international names. The All-Star Game was primarily a domestic affair.

DP era (2007-2015): Designated Players like David Beckham, Thierry Henry, Robbie Keane, and David Villa became All-Star fixtures, lending star power to the event. The All-Star Game increasingly featured recognizable international names.

Modern era (2016-present): Rosters now include a mix of high-profile DPs, homegrown products, and TAM-level contributors. The talent pool is deeper, and All-Star selections are more competitive. Players like Riqui Puig, Cucho Hernandez, and Lucho Acosta represent a generation of MLS stars who are in their prime years, not their twilight.

Fan Voting Controversies

Fan voting has occasionally produced results that coaches and analysts question. Popular players on large-market teams sometimes receive more votes than statistically superior players on smaller-market clubs. This is a common issue in all-star voting across all sports, and MLS has mitigated it by supplementing fan picks with commissioner and coaching staff selections.

The Economics of the All-Star Game

The All-Star Game is a meaningful revenue event for MLS and the host city.

Host City Selection

Host cities are selected through a bidding process similar to other major sporting events. Factors include:

  • Stadium quality and capacity
  • Local soccer fan base and market size
  • Hotel and infrastructure capacity for visiting fans and media
  • Financial commitments from the host city and state
  • Willingness to support ancillary events (Skills Challenge, concerts, fan festivals)

Recent host cities -- Columbus, Washington D.C., Minneapolis, Los Angeles -- reflect MLS's preference for markets with strong soccer followings and modern venues.

Revenue Generation

The All-Star Game generates revenue through:

  • Gate receipts: Capacity crowds at 20,000-70,000 seat venues
  • Broadcasting: Apple TV coverage (domestic) plus international distribution
  • Sponsorship: All-Star-specific sponsor activations and branding
  • Merchandise: All-Star-specific jerseys, scarves, and other merchandise
  • Tourism: Hotel bookings, restaurant spending, and other economic impact in the host city

The total economic impact of an All-Star Game week on a host city is estimated at $30-$50 million, making it one of the more impactful single events MLS produces annually.

What Is Next for the All-Star Game Format?

MLS has not committed to a permanent format, and there is ongoing discussion about future directions.

Continuing MLS vs. Liga MX

The Liga MX format has been well-received, and the genuine rivalry provides competitive stakes that previous formats lacked. As long as MLS and Liga MX remain the two dominant leagues in CONCACAF, this matchup carries natural appeal.

Potential International Expansion

Some have suggested expanding the concept to include other leagues -- MLS vs. the Premier League, MLS vs. a South American all-star team, or even a four-league tournament. These ideas are logistically complex (scheduling, player availability, travel) but could elevate the event's global profile.

A Return to Internal Formats

There have been occasional calls to return to an East vs. West or some other internal format, particularly from fans who want to see MLS players compete against each other rather than external opponents. However, the internal format's history of low-stakes, high-scoring exhibitions makes a return unlikely. The league's competitive comparison to European leagues like the Premier League also suggests that external opponents generate more interest.

Key Takeaways

The MLS All-Star Game has evolved from a forgettable internal exhibition to a genuine event on the North American soccer calendar. The shift to MLS vs. Liga MX has given the game competitive meaning, while the Skills Challenge and surrounding events have turned it into a multi-day festival. MLS's undefeated record against Liga MX All-Stars also serves as a statement about the league's competitive trajectory -- a topic explored in depth in our MLS vs. Liga MX comparison.

This article was generated with the assistance of AI. All game results, attendance figures, and format details are based on publicly available MLS records, official league announcements, and verified sports reporting. Some historical details, particularly from early All-Star Games, may be approximate where official records are limited.