John McCarthy vs Philip Quinton

John McCarthy

Philip Quinton

Comparing a goalkeeper to a defender requires looking at different dimensions. John McCarthy guards the net for New York Red Bulls while Philip Quinton plays defender for Real Salt Lake. Both players represent USA on the international stage. Philip Quinton has contributed 0 goals and 2 assists. At 26, Philip Quinton is 7 years younger than the 33-year-old John McCarthy.