The best season in FC Cincinnati history was 2023, winning the Supporters' Shield with the best regular-season record. This campaign stands out as the high-water mark for the franchise, featuring exceptional performances from key players and memorable moments that are still celebrated by fans today.
Great seasons in MLS are defined by a combination of regular-season consistency, playoff success, and the overall narrative of the campaign. For FC Cincinnati, this particular season captured the imagination of Cincinnati and demonstrated the club's potential to compete at the highest level of North American soccer.